In a rare move highlighting growing unease within the judiciary, Justice Mansoor Ali Shah has written a seven-page letter to Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Yahya Afridi, raising six pressing questions over key judicial matters, including the handling of the 26th Constitutional Amendment petitions.

The letter by Justice Shah was sent directly to the Chief Justice after several earlier communications reportedly went unanswered. He emphasized that, as the most senior judge after the CJP, it was his duty to seek clarity on institutional concerns that had already surfaced publicly during the Judicial Conference on September 8.

In his detailed letter, Justice Shah asked why no meeting of the Practice and Procedure Committee was called and why the Supreme Court Rules were approved through circulation instead of a full court session. He further questioned the method of individual consultations on changing the policy for issuing dissenting notes.

Read More: Bilawal Bhutto acknowledges Maryam Nawaz’s efforts in flood-hit Punjab

Other queries included the issuance of a general order regarding judges’ vacations, the decision not to form an original full court to hear petitions against the 26th Amendment, and why judges were being treated more as a “controlled force” rather than being allowed greater independence.

Justice Mansoor Ali Shah underlined that these questions are not just internal matters but issues of public trust in the judiciary. He expressed hope that the Chief Justice would address them openly during the ceremony marking the start of the new judicial year.